Portland Press Herald / Maine Sunday Telegram
Tribe calls vote a put-down
Printer-friendly version Reader Comments
story tools
sponsored by
Election 2007: Passamaquoddys say they can't help but suspect discrimination led to the defeat.
BY JOSIE HUANG, Staff Writer November 8, 2007
John Ewing/Staff Photographer
enlarge
John Ewing/Staff Photographer
Clayton Cleaves, executive director of the Pleasant Point reservation’s housing authority, says discrimination played a role in defeating the racino. “I know, in the voting equation, there are people who hate Native Americans,” he said.
John Ewing/Staff Photographer
enlarge
John Ewing/Staff Photographer
Rick Doyle, governor of the Passamaquoddy reservation at Pleasant Point, says the tribe isn’t ready to give up on a racino.
John Ewing/Staff Photographer
enlarge
John Ewing/Staff Photographer
Mike Chadwick, who is principal of the reservation’s school but not a tribe member, says the racino’s defeat is a major blow. “You have the poorest county in the state ... and they’re being denied opportunity,” he said.

PLEASANT POINT — The day after the Passamaquoddys lost their second bid in four years to build a gambling operation, a fellow tribe member caught up with Gov. Rick Doyle in the parking lot for tribal offices.

"Well, the cowboys beat the Indians again," the man said.

Doyle, who just 12 hours earlier had been talking about how a harness racing track with slot machines would deliver his tribe from poverty, said the man's comment summed up the feelings on the reservation Wednesday.

"Every time we propose something, we get put down," Doyle said. "It feels to me that we continue to be oppressed by the dominant culture."

There are plans to build a liquefied natural gas terminal in Passamaquoddy Bay, and strong interest in harnessing tidal waters and the wind for energy production ventures. But the tribe has focused for nearly 15 years on getting a gambling facility, and the latest setback only reinforced nagging suspicions that voters were discriminating against the tribe and Washington County, where the racino would have been built.

For leaders, the defeat was even more disappointing because the tribe had poured more than $700,000 into the ballot campaign and convinced neighboring communities that opposed past efforts to see the racino as a potential economic engine that would generate jobs and encourage tourism.

"We thought we put together a pretty good package," said Lt. Gov. Joseph Socobasin of the Passamaquoddy council in Indian Township.

Tribe members said anti-casino forces proved too formidable. Political action committees fought their proposal; Gov. John Baldacci vetoed a bill to allow a racino, setting the stage for the referendum; and voters in more urban and populated parts of the state, with their numbers, helped defeat the measure 52 percent to 48 percent.

As elders played cards in the senior center at the edge of the bay, Bonnie Sockabasin said she has the impression that many people in southern Maine are transplants who want to keep gambling facilities out of their new home.

Sockabasin, a cook at the center, said they have no regard for the harsh economic reality facing the tribe and Washington County, which has the state's highest unemployment rate because of job losses in the manufacturing and fishing industries.

"If we just had the numbers that southern Maine has, then we would have had a good shot at getting the racino," she said.

Clayton Cleaves, executive director of the reservation's housing authority, noted the narrowness of the defeat, and said that had racists not voted, the measure surely would have passed.

"I know, in the voting equation, there are people who hate Native Americans," Cleaves said.

Those who ran the campaign against the racino said racism did not decide the vote.

Dennis Bailey of Casinos No! said the political action group actually had to overcome a lot of sympathy for the tribe and Washington County.

"There were many people and voters who under normal circumstances would never vote for the casino, but they were willing to say, 'Let them do it if that's what they want to do,"' Bailey said.

Bailey attributed the tribe's loss more to the fact that a racino already exists in Maine. In 2003, when voters rejected a proposal by the Passamaquoddy and Penobscot tribes to build a casino in southern Maine, they authorized limited slot-machine gambling at existing harness racing tracks.

That led the gaming corporation Penn National to open Hollywood Slots in Bangor.

"I think there is the perception of voters that they were fooled" in 2003, Bailey said. "Racinos are a harder sell now."

Bailey said the Passamaquoddys and the anti-casino movement do share one belief – that it is unfair for Penn National to have a racino monopoly.

On Wednesday, the group invited Maine's Indian tribes to join the fight to ban all slot machines in the state "in the interest of eradicating this blatant...


Reader comments
Click here to view or add comments on this story

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form