Clearing the Bases Blog Index
December 11, 2008
Lugo for Eric Byrnes?

Steve Phillips of ESPN reported early this morning that the Red Sox and Arizona Diamondbacks are discussing a trade involving shortstop Julio Lugo and outfielder Eric Byrnes.

It would be an exchange of bad contracts.

Lugo has not done much in his two years with Boston (granted, the Red Sox won a World Series with him in 2007) and Jed Lowrie took his job last year. Lugo still has two years and $18-million left on the contract.

Byrnes, who turns 33 next February, has two years and $22-million left on his contract (a three-year deal he signed last year). According to mlb.com, Byrnes tore both his hamstrings last year, tried to comeback and strained one of them, ending his season. He played in only 52 games (batting .209).

His best season was 2007 (.286, 21 HR, 83 RBI).

Byrnes, a right-handed bat, would become Boston's fourth outfielder, the same spot he would likely have in Arizona. Byrnes would have to approve the deal. He reportedly has a no-trade contract.

In another report from the winter meetings, the Washington Nationals have apparently offered Mark Teixeira an 8-year, $160-million deal. Looks like Teixeira might get $200-million before it is all over.

As for C.C. Sabathia's 7-year, $161-million deal, if he averages 15 wins a season for those 7 years, he will make just over $1.5-million a win. Expensive, yes. But the Yankees badly needed a frontline starter.

Posted at 05:45 AM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

Where's t he value added in that trade? Lower career batting average lower than Lugo and suspicious health. How about a major league ready young catcher instead of another outfielder? Oakland wants a Shortstop and Kurt Suzuki is young and more than ready.

Posted by Thom in West Bath
December 11, 2008 07:14 AM

I like the trade, the Sox need another outfielder, and everyone hates Lugo. Eric Byrnes is a gamer and Lugo is a bench warmer. Sure you probably think Byrnes will be a benchwarmer, but he's way better than Lugo.

Posted by Anthony in Portland
December 12, 2008 12:11 PM

I like the trade, the Sox need another outfielder, and everyone hates Lugo. Eric Byrnes is a gamer and Lugo is a bench warmer. Sure you probably think Byrnes will be a benchwarmer, but he's way better than Lugo.

Posted by Anthony in Portland
December 12, 2008 12:11 PM

oh please please please let this be true! great post, kevin. lugo is useless with the sox, and byrnes, though flighty and with the bad wheels, still has a chance to be a decent 4th outfielder, something the sox badly need. let's hope theo gets to pull the trigger on this one.

Posted by joe sweeney
December 13, 2008 09:20 AM

send Ellsbury instead, Lugo had a better on base percentage in '08 and is way underrated.

Posted by KG
December 19, 2008 11:08 PM

You are insane if you want Byrnes in Boston. I'm telling you this from watching the Dbacks in Arizona and watching the majority of Sox games on cable. Byrnes played out of his mind his contract year and has been a waste otherwise. He's a wuss when it comes to injury. He's also the a gigantic Primadona. You can find a 4th outfielder more than worthy anywhere else for much cheaper, and he'll play. Yes lugo sucks. Move him for a catcher though and toss in a middle reliever. Don't go after Byrnes. You'll regret it. I will laugh at you.

Posted by Steve
December 22, 2008 09:57 AM

You are insane if you want Byrnes in Boston. I'm telling you this from watching the Dbacks in Arizona and watching the majority of Sox games on cable. Byrnes played out of his mind his contract year and has been a waste otherwise. He's a wuss when it comes to injury. He's also the a gigantic Primadona. You can find a 4th outfielder more than worthy anywhere else for much cheaper, and he'll play. Yes lugo sucks. Move him for a catcher though and toss in a middle reliever. Don't go after Byrnes. You'll regret it. I will laugh at you.

Posted by Steve
December 22, 2008 09:58 AM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index

Kevin covers baseball for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram. He first reported on spring training games for the St. Petersburg Times in 1978. He wisely moved to Maine in 1994 and now writes about the Portland Sea Dogs and Boston Red Sox—when he's not coaching Little League baseball.

He is married to Nancy, and the couple recently completed their lineup card with the birth of their ninth child.



Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
Farewell Top Dog (7)
Bob Moore wrote: I had the pleasure of getting to spend the last 7 years of "Tourney Time" w...

Dogs to play at Fenway again (3)
Mary Maloney wrote: Hello, I am deputy dog, otherwise known as Marty Jensen's daughter. Harold...

Becoming Manny: A lesson in irresponsibility (4)
nadia wrote: good review. I just can not believe that Manny wants to SQUEEZE every last...

Former Dogs catcher sues Jose Offerman for $4.8-million (1)
copyeditor wrote: Yikes, please get a proofreader. There are multiple typos/mistakes in this ...

A-Who? (10)
hmmm... wrote: But to be fair, "prof" isn't a word either, it's professor. ;p...

Does money make the man? (6)
ELS wrote: Chas, the only incentives in the contract raise the value of the player opt...

Archives
By category
Minors (16)
Red Sox (325)
By date
July 08 (54)
June 08 (54)
May 08 (50)
July 07 (28)
June 07 (34)
May 07 (39)