Log In | Register | Help
Clearing the Bases Blog Index
June 11, 2007
Trade Wily Mo, elevate Ellsbury

What would you do to strengthen the Boston Red Sox lineup?

Yes, the Red Sox are in first place. But can the Red Sox sit on their success over the first two months? I doubt if Theo and company are sitting in cruise control.

Moves will likely be made. Here is my humble suggestion for a move.

Trade Wily Mo Pena to the highest bidder (if there is one) and promote Jacoby Ellsbury to Boston.

Here are the advantages:
Ellsbury give you two factors: a leadoff hitter and a solid-hitting center fielder.
Shortstop Julio Lugo, with his .214 batting and .274 on-base percentage, can move down in the lineup.

Center fielder Coco Crisp becomes the Alex Cora of the outfield, i.e. a back-up who plays often (giving Ellsbury time to settle in). He can pinch-hit (a switch-hitter) and can obviously pinch run.

Wily Mo no longer becomes a defensive liability for Boston. A trade would also be fair for Pena. He is not getting enough at-bats (83, so far, with a ,241 average and four home runs) to establish himself and he is coming up on free agency (after 2008).

What are the risks?
Ellsbury is not proven in the majors. But like Dustin Pedroia, Ellsbury succeeds everywhere he goes. Give him time to settle in, and he will.

Crisp may not like the deal. But what leverage does he have with a .224 batting average?

After trading Bronson Arroyo for Pena, Boston will likely get little now for Pena. Well, look at Arroyo now (2-7, 5.01 ERA). The Arroyo-for-Pena trade was a decent risk, if Pena turned into a consistent power hitter. That is not likely going to happen in the next year and a half.

So, that's my suggestion for the Boston brain trust. What's yours?


Posted at 10:35 PM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

I really like the idea of trading Wily Mo Pena, although I would be hesitant to rush Ellsbury to the majors. Coca Crisp still provides excellent defense--and that's needed to protect Manny in left. He (Crisp) can stay around for another year, then I would consider moving Ellsbury up.

I think Mike Timlin's days in Boston need to come to a close as well. Unload him and Wily Mo together and attempt to get some sort of veteran reliever (namely a power thrower to compliment Papelbon).

Posted by Jason
June 12, 2007 07:37 AM

I'm all for it, but what could you get in return? I would rather see the team pursue a Lugo and Coco deal for Michael Young at this point. But Texas needs pitching so toss in a Hansen and we may be able to pry a better shortstop and promote Ellsbury. Ellsbury can do no worse than Coco.

Posted by Ed Walsh
June 12, 2007 11:16 AM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?







Please enter the code as seen in the image above:



Blog Index

Kevin covers baseball for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram. He first reported on spring training games for the St. Petersburg Times in 1978. He wisely moved to Maine in 1994 and now writes about the Portland Sea Dogs and Boston Red Sox—when he's not coaching Little League baseball.

He is married to Nancy, and the couple recently completed their lineup card with the birth of their ninth child.



Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
Top 10 Red Sox prospects (8)
Andrew Michaelson wrote: All I have to say is that we shouldn't forget the Sox' top 2 prospects -- B...

Pitchers coming up (1)
Simon Thompson wrote: I agree with you, I still don't see how Masterson could be sent to Pawtucke...

Mitchell Report hits and misses (2)
Jeremy wrote: I'll hold judgment until I hear more information. I don't, however, believ...

What do Red Sox, Yankees need? (1)
Jeremy wrote: While I wouldn't MIND having Santana, I have to agree with the mentioned ph...

Would you give up Clay Buchholz? (5)
Mark wrote: Santana's ERA at Fenway is based on 15 innings. His ERA against Boston over...

So much for Santana (5)
Christopher in Queens wrote: I don't think that the Sox should give up Ellsbury. I'd rather they give u...

Archives
By category
Minors (1)
Red Sox (143)
By date
July 07 (28)
June 07 (34)
May 07 (39)