Search Maine Yellow Pages 
Log In | Register | Help
On Environment Blog Index
March 17, 2007
Maine at a crosswind

Maine’s efforts to lead the region as a producer of wind power have been a case of one step forward, two steps back.

A wind farm in Mars Hill started spinning this winter, while two others – one on the Redington range near Sugarloaf and another in Freedom – hit regulatory opposition. The Freedom project was stalled by the local board of appeals last week while Redington appears headed toward a final rejection in April or May by the Maine Land Use Regulation Commission.

Some fear the early mixed-signals could scare away investors and wind developers. Now, however, the state is facing a few big opportunities to regain its footing and set a clearer course. And, if you listen closely, you might hear the sound of a future state study commission blowing in the wind.

Two large-scale wind power proposals are now pending before the Land Use Regulation Commission, which oversees zoning and development in the state’s unorganized territories. One includes 44 wind turbines on Kibby Mountain and Kibby Range in Franklin County. The other, submitted within the past two weeks, proposes 38 wind turbines on Stetson Mountain in Washington County.

What happens with those two projects over the next several months could have a big impact on whether more projects come forward and whether the state achieves its goal of generating 10 percent of our energy from renewable resources by 2017.

Gov. Baldacci and others have hopes for experimental technologies, such as tapping Maine’s powerful tides or turning its trees into ethanol to fuel cars and trucks. But wind farm developers are the ones knocking on the door now.

Expect the State House to weigh in soon. There is one bill, sponsored by Sen. Ethan Strimling, D-Portland, that would streamline review of wind projects. Another, sponsored by Lawrence Jacobsen, R-Waterboro, would create a commission to promote environmentally sound alternatives to foreign oil. Other proposals kicking around Augusta include a legislative resolution to affirm the state’s support for wind energy.

Gov. Baldacci, meanwhile, continues to express his support. But a question facing the administration now is whether to hope the two latest projects catch a fair wind and move forward, or pull everyone together – including developers, wind advocates and opponents – to try developing a unified state policy and siting guidelines.

Posted by at 06:35 AM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

Do not know what so bad with wind power?? Nothing as long as it not in my backyard ?? They do not look that bad! If I had $$ I would put one up.
Maybe good idea to find a way to warn off birds!!

About 5/6 years ago I went on tour of Spain and we went to Morocco for 2 days. The African coast was very mountainous and was just lined with windmills, miles of them. Are they trying to save oil?

Back 100 years every farm in Maine had at least one windmill

Posted by Norman Jordan
March 17, 2007 09:35 AM

let's renew the fernald act: ok to do wind power, BUT, the power must be used in maine.

Posted by bill butler
March 17, 2007 10:54 AM

A HORNET 600(watt) wind mill base price is $499..less mounting tower, inverter, battery for storage.

It it works you can add more to make your own wind farm.

Starting small makes all the sense in the world; but these huge wind farms controlled by out of state corporations will ruin the market for small, home/farm/business installations and net metering.

Please stop promoting these 'showcase' trophy sites.

Posted by fjh
March 17, 2007 01:23 PM

fjh, WELL SAID!

This giant out of state corporation is pushing this project down our throats. Why? To make money!! Privatization of energy is a big problem that has wreaked havoc all over the earth. REMEMBER ENRON?! That is the first step- take away these monopolies in the power industry.

If each town could simply create its own wind power systems, or if this giant project was state sponsored then I think Mainers would be more receptive.

John, see the big picture and stop catering to these prepackaged mass media notions of environmetal debate. Or are you still afraid of being called a tree-hugger?

Posted by Bill Brasky
March 18, 2007 11:36 AM

Would those that oppose wind power in Maine be willing to live without electricity? Surely their lives currently result in the consumption of electricity produced as the result of some damage done to the planet. What alternatives do they recommend?
Nay-sating is easy, coming up with viable alternatives is much harder.

I agree that if Maine allows our "resource" to be used, then it must be owned and operated to profit Maine, not line the pockets of already wealthy corporations.

Posted by Jason Simonds
March 18, 2007 11:38 AM

Properly sited wind industry could benefit Maine. These large scale industrial proposals in undeveloped areas are what many people, myself included, oppose. LURC showed amazing foresight in turning down Reddington and I hope both Kibby and Stetson go down as well.

Siting guidlines need to be established and areas with exisiting industrial development seem the logical place for Maine to get into the wind business.

Posted by kev
March 18, 2007 06:25 PM

Mr. Richardson's story implies there is something wrong with the regulatory system that needs to be fixed because two recent wind power projects have been rejected by public review agencies.

Apparently, this is "problem."

I would say this indicates the system is working exactly how it should -- weeding out those projects that do not pass regulatory muster.

Mr. Richardson then suggests that, essentially, a state committee be created to override existing regulatory bodies, like LURC, for the specific purpose of guaranteeing that wind power projects are never denied.

This is nothing more than throwing away the rule book just because it won't let you do exactly what you want, where you want, all the time.

Mr. Richardson cannot cite a single specific problem with the existing permit review process for wind power -- except that it does not automatically approve all projects and can result in denials.

Why not suggest Gov. Baldacci tell all of Maine's judges to overturn all denials of wind power projects that come before them ?

And what does "streamline" mean ? This is nothing more than a deceptive and dishonest euphemism for gutting the rules so projects that do meet legal muster suddenly and magically meet legal muster.

Why not be honest and call it what it is: cooking the books.


Posted by Douglas Watts
March 19, 2007 09:00 AM

Mr. Richardson writes:

"Maine’s efforts to lead the region as a producer of wind power have been a case of one step forward, two steps back."

When did the people of Maine say this was their goal and intent ? Who said it ? When ?

In sentence logic this is called an embedded assumption. Assumed to be true, but never shown to be true. It has no place in good journalism since it slants the entire story and issue and perspective from the get-go.

C'mon folks, let's have some more broad-based and open-minded reportage here. PPH and Mr. Richardson are certainly up to it, and it mean that sincerely. Cheers.

Posted by
March 19, 2007 02:08 PM

I dare Mr. Richardson to take on the topic of energy privatization.

Posted by Bill Brasky
March 20, 2007 09:21 AM

Upstate NY is dealing with a similar battle between industrial scale and residential turbines. So far, towns have shown a willingness to embrace small scale wind collection, but the projects that propose 40 370-foot turbines have met with opposition, mainly because people are seeing them as boondoggles for the energy companies, who receive subsidies. The wind "farms" do little for the local area, other than paying a few select land owners. Also, the working life of the towers is about 20 years, after that, the town is stuck with them.
Here is a site that talks about what's happening:
http://www.delcowind.org/

Posted by as
March 21, 2007 11:24 AM

I do not wish to have any windmill running through my prppert and we keep paying a higher cost for everything anyway so what difference does paying more for power. the people that want it let it be put in their backyards not ours that don't want it.

Posted by brenda white
May 19, 2007 07:49 PM

bzJhqO ojhyxsqlqkne, [url=http://htlxvocyeckr.com/]htlxvocyeckr[/url], [link=http://iplvjwnusyhe.com/]iplvjwnusyhe[/link], http://phdvvramwwba.com/

Posted by myrziqtmk
June 1, 2008 07:23 PM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?







Please enter the code as seen in the image above:



Blog Index

John covers environmental issues for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram. A reporter for 20 years, he always hoped to find some use for his undergraduate degree in International Environmental Studies. He also has a master's degree in journalism, though back then they taught writing on a thing called a typewriter. He's married and has two children.

About this blog

Down To Earth is a place to keep tabs on the environment beat at the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram. Staff Writer John Richardson will post updates on past news stories, share tidbits and behind-the-story stories, answer questions and get feedback and ideas from you.



Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
Seeing 'ghosts' in the Maine woods (5)
Shellie wrote: Beedlerd, We have had three sightings here on the midcoast of maine last fa...

Coastal communities serious about reducing pesticides (2)
Ron Huber wrote: Another important reason to sharply reduce coastal pesticide use is to prot...

Endangered: Staffing cuts threaten Maine’s wildlife refuges (1)
Virtual Pet wrote: Sorry to hear that there are budget cuts. Wildlife preservation is such an...

Air, water and Maine giant (1)
jbascgbh wrote: CNCQNc zcqtsotwffxs, [url=http://aqvatwxcavoe.com/]aqvatwxcavoe[/url], [li...

Maine’s Catholic Church goes green, too (1)
hekivvenypy wrote: go6Ygw sklkilgczagh, [url=http://afaqpffbfdfd.com/]afaqpffbfdfd[/url], [li...

Cars: Can't live with 'em ... (4)
gfquabzwus wrote: 7so95r txekmvebaxjb, [url=http://vnwkrsyfguco.com/]vnwkrsyfguco[/url], [li...