Nxt Blog Index
August 05, 2008
The Press Herald is Dead...Long Live the Press Herald?

Unless you've been stuck on a mountain in Maine the last few days, you've probably picked up on the latest meme of the moment: "The Press Herald is Shutting Its Doors."

While that's not the case (for today at least - hey, we live in tricky times here) it does provide us with another look at the sticky intersection of the news business, technology and where (if anywhere) it's all going.

We can thank WGME for kicking things off the other day with a story that indicated money troubles could mean your daily newspaper could be closing in the near future.

By this morning the ball had been picked up and the story (thanks to the AP) was making the rounds at the Bangor Daily News, The Lewiston Sun Journal and on the other coast at our parent company - The Seattle Times. Along the way blogs, forums and other observers on the journalism deadpool watch picked up on the story, including Editor & Publisher and Poynter's Romenesko.

Now, it's fair game to point out that our own publisher stated the possibility of a shutdown in court documents - this is a fact.

Most folks also know that we've had our share of painful cutbacks and bloodletting here in the last year - this is also a fact.

It's no secret that these are bad times for newspapers - According to Papercuts we're down more than 7,000 jobs industry wide just this year.

(Bonus: Pop quiz on newspaper economics!)

So is it any surprise that people would jump on the idea that their local (or, "yet another") newspaper was on life-support and about to have the plug pulled?

An observation I've had in recent weeks when people talk to me about the fate of the Press Herald, is the idea that people can't imagine what it would be like to not have a newspaper. Folks can't seem to picture a Portland without some sort of newspaper. (The AP and other local news sources should consider that too - it could mean less content for them)

While that's a nice sentiment, I thought it was odd considering how much circulation has changed and how many people don't read the physical paper on a daily basis.

It'd be nice and heartwarming in a "clap-your-hands-if-you-believe-in-journalism" sort of way to think "they don't read us, but they know they need us."

But why do they need us? Slate's Press Box says newspapers used to provide the "cultural currency" that people needed in their daily lives:"

"For as long as anybody can remember, the newspaper has been the primary info-hub through which people interacted. Oh, people might have talked to the shoe-shine man or their broker about what they heard on the radio or saw on television, but nothing could beat the newspaper as a source for socially lubricating conversation. How many times have you heard a conversation start, 'Didja see that article ...'"

Those days are dying at an increased rate because so many other avenues online can provide that service. People share news on Facebook, they talk headlines over Twitter, they keep up with sports on their favorite blogs. (Also, maybe because the shoe-shine man hasn't gotten steady work since the Carter administration.)

And this brings me back to my question before - if people don't read us, why do they need us? Is it sentimentality? Nostalgia? A glimmer of hope?

Now that I think about it, maybe all those people were just humoring me...


SOUND OFF! (I've been told the comments work again, so have at it!)

Posted by at 03:47 PM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

The delivery message may be on the verge of changing (if anyone could figure out exactly how to change it) but the reporters and the news gathering will always be needed. There is no google news w/ out newspapers for it to pull the stories from. The AP and the local radio / tv stations would have to double their staffs to make up for the news they pull from the PPH source.

I think people feel they can't imagine life in Portland without the newspaper but what they really can't imagine is life with out a daily news source, without a staff working to produce new content every day.

Its time to find a way to make delivering that news profitable so we don't lose any more of our reporters.

Posted by ac
August 5, 2008 07:14 PM

The news isn't all bad ...

In the developing world:

http://www.economist.com/business/displayStory.cfm?source=hptextfeature&story_id=11792392

Posted by Alex Steed
August 5, 2008 10:25 PM

The death of the PPH would be one of saddest moments in not just Maine media, but Maine business as well. The idea that there is not enough business acumen and knowledge of contemporary media models within this state to keep PPH, not just up and running, but a journalistic and news powerhouse is just insulting. I can only assume that the current situation is due to a bottleneck caused by ego and fear. If the powers that be took a step aside and let people that they know should have charge of certain situations, everything would be just fine. But the idea that the PPH will die is RIDICULOUS. Lose money for a bit, sure. But not die.

Posted by Dan
August 6, 2008 10:33 AM

People measure the value of things by what surrounds them. They may not buy the paper, but they like to know they live in a city that produces news enough for a paper. Perception is key.

If the paper folds or goes on hiatus, I think the people of Portland will be more estranged from each other. Whatever binding that the paper gives to those who read it will be lost.

I hope that your writing will not be lost in this turmoil.

Posted by Doug E.
August 6, 2008 11:01 AM

I would miss my paper, some days the only exercise I get is walking to the mailbox! I want something I can carry around with me for my news source. I want the obits to make sure I am not among them, I need my crossword to make sure I still got my brains. I need the tv listings, the movie listings. The editorial page so I can what the geniuses around town are saying. Please keep the paper!

Posted by JEB
August 6, 2008 02:56 PM

use digital TV to produce a full colour version of the PPH broadcast with ad space on screen...(no broken articles ie each page has complete article) Every 5 minutes turn the page-so people have a chance to read it.

Posted by yamo
August 6, 2008 05:22 PM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index

Justin is a former newspaper intern and has the scar tissue to prove it. Justin has been a staff writer for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram since 2003, and in 2004 began writing a weekly column in the Monday Magazine.

If he had to pick a label, the column would fall under "youth culture," covering everything from high school dance etiquette, dealing with college debt, the resurgence of Roller Derby and Portland's one-of-a-kind music scene. This of course has not stopped him from answering letters to Santa Claus or writing about his experience riding shotgun in a drift car.

Justin is an export from the Midwest. He is a graduate of the University of Missouri and is originally from Minnesota. He enjoys bacon, cheap beer, redheads, Burt Reynolds jokes and wondering what the soundtrack to his life would sound like.

When he grows up he wants to be an international art thief. Or Captain America.

Until then he'll be bringing you dispatches about "the young people" and what they do.






WAYS TO LISTEN
1) Use the player above

2) Subscribe
ITUNES other podcast client

3) Direct Download
IE: Right-click select 'Save Target As
Mac: Control-click select 'Save Link As'.mp3
Bring on the Tights: Free Comic Book Day
Celebrating Vinyl at Enterprise Records
The NXT Roundtable: The economy & doughnuts
South by Southwest Interactive: Talking with Jay Smooth
The Night at Greendrinks
The NXT Roundtable
Day at the Newseum
Subject Bias: How to Feel
ROFLing with "Stuff White People Like"
Geekspeak with Pop Candy
A Green Eye for Fashion
Not My Job
What's next for Justin Alfond
Sittin' down with Stew n' Crew
Lessons with the Portland Music Foundation
Catching up with Opportunity Maine
Discussing Freedom Space
Spinout's Class of 2007
Free for All in Space
Flipping Records: WMPG's Annual Record Sale
An evening at the MECA art auction
Beats, award shows and life with Mike Clouds
The NXT Halloween Special
Chat with Davy Rothbart of FOUND Magazine
When Turtles Make Love *Warning: mature material
Derby night in America
The debut of Halo 3
A sit down with Santiago




Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
SOUND OFF: Time Warner Drops Plan to Put a Meter on the Internet (UPDATED) (2)
David Rooker wrote: I'm against metered internet usage. It's trying to get more money for a se...

New Podcast: Celebrating Vinyl at Enterprise Records (1)
Jim wrote: Vinyl is one of the remaining beautiful things from a pre-Twitter world. ...

Shirt Party - Meet Local Ink Tonight (2)
Sharky wrote: Local Ink's t-shirts are listed at $80 - $92 on their site. Man, those shir...

The Monday Fix: DIY Funerals, AmazonFail and bacon-infused bourbon (1)
Dad Is Dying wrote: Speaking of DIY funerals: http://www.homefuneralmanual.org/...

Press Play with Videoport Jones - Yes Man, Doubt and The Day the Earth Stood Still (1)
Videoport Jones wrote: Justin, I am shocked, shocked I say, that you (or someone in the shadowy c...

Bracketstravaganza Winners and Losers (2)
JEB wrote: There is that Justin Bobble Head again! I want one!...