Nxt Blog Index
June 25, 2008
With great blogging, comes great respectability

I've found myself pondering lots of new media questions recently, especially after the bloggers vs. AP affair from last week.

Though that battle was over rights, preconditions, money and fear, one of the bigger questions that emerged was where bloggers get their content and how they (and the AP for that matter) fit into the "Age of New Media."

This week another dispatch has me wondering what's the end game for bloggers and what they write.

Perhaps you've heard of Will Leitch, author of "God Save the Fan," and soon to be former editor of the sports blog Deadspin.

In his last week on the job he sent what amounts to a warning shot to other sports bloggers: Stay true to who you are and what you write.

A little back story: A few months ago Leitch was part of what can now be called an infamous segment on Bob Costas' HBO show "Costas Now" about sports, sports writing and the Internets.

What was most interesting about the episode was the spectacular explosion by author Buzz Bissinger at Leitch and blogs in general. To sum up, the author of books like "Friday Night Lights" and "Three Nights in August," basically said blogs, and bloggers like Leitch could not carry (and were not fit to carry) his jock strap. (Watch the video for yourself. NOTE - includes some colorful language. Seriously.)

This moment spawned another great blogstorm with online writers drawing battle lines between themselves and the old guard (mainstream) sports writers.

The Boston Phoenix has an interesting look at the grudge match between old and new media in the sports world, and wonders with the rest of the mainstream staring to play nice with online, why can't the sporting geeks.

On Sunday the LA Times ran a story where a number of sports bloggers ruminated on whether it was time to class up the world of sports blogging.

And this brings us back to Leitch and his central question - why would you change what you're doing now? Is it because you feel a newfound sense of responsibility that was absent before? Is it because the old hounds of the sports game have made you feel shame? Is it book deals?

He asks:
"If something is worthwhile to post if you're getting 10 readers a day, shouldn't you stand behind it if you have a million readers a day? Changing what you do because you've become more popular is exactly why Bill Plaschke and Rick Reilly have declined so dramatically. Isn't that what this is all supposed to be against?"

Now while Leitch is talking specifically about sports bloggers, doesn't the question really apply to everyone in the blogging game and what got them there?

In some ways it seems to come down to that old fashion idea of "selling out." Is it like when your favorite band gets signed by the big label and their music sounds more produced. Or when your idealistic friend takes a buttoned-down job at a hedge fund.

The world of blogs is no different, as there are plenty of examples of writers taking jobs with larger, more established newspapers, magazines or other publications. And let's not forget book deals, plenty of book deals.

With blogs and other new media soaring in popularity and readers and old media scrambling to realign, isn't this the best time for bloggers to do what they do best, or what got them noticed in the first place.

It seems like years ago the question was where blogs fit into the media landscape, and the fight by their authors for legitimacy. Arguably bloggers have helped remake that landscape, so do they still need to find that "legitimacy" or approval?

Does it all come down to what motivates people to write blogs? Are blogs just vehicles to bigger success?


Posted by at 11:46 AM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index

Justin is a former newspaper intern and has the scar tissue to prove it. Justin has been a staff writer for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram since 2003, and in 2004 began writing a weekly column in the Monday Magazine.

If he had to pick a label, the column would fall under "youth culture," covering everything from high school dance etiquette, dealing with college debt, the resurgence of Roller Derby and Portland's one-of-a-kind music scene. This of course has not stopped him from answering letters to Santa Claus or writing about his experience riding shotgun in a drift car.

Justin is an export from the Midwest. He is a graduate of the University of Missouri and is originally from Minnesota. He enjoys bacon, cheap beer, redheads, Burt Reynolds jokes and wondering what the soundtrack to his life would sound like.

When he grows up he wants to be an international art thief. Or Captain America.

Until then he'll be bringing you dispatches about "the young people" and what they do.






WAYS TO LISTEN
1) Use the player above

2) Subscribe
ITUNES other podcast client

3) Direct Download
IE: Right-click select 'Save Target As
Mac: Control-click select 'Save Link As'.mp3
Bring on the Tights: Free Comic Book Day
Celebrating Vinyl at Enterprise Records
The NXT Roundtable: The economy & doughnuts
South by Southwest Interactive: Talking with Jay Smooth
The Night at Greendrinks
The NXT Roundtable
Day at the Newseum
Subject Bias: How to Feel
ROFLing with "Stuff White People Like"
Geekspeak with Pop Candy
A Green Eye for Fashion
Not My Job
What's next for Justin Alfond
Sittin' down with Stew n' Crew
Lessons with the Portland Music Foundation
Catching up with Opportunity Maine
Discussing Freedom Space
Spinout's Class of 2007
Free for All in Space
Flipping Records: WMPG's Annual Record Sale
An evening at the MECA art auction
Beats, award shows and life with Mike Clouds
The NXT Halloween Special
Chat with Davy Rothbart of FOUND Magazine
When Turtles Make Love *Warning: mature material
Derby night in America
The debut of Halo 3
A sit down with Santiago




Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
SOUND OFF: Time Warner Drops Plan to Put a Meter on the Internet (UPDATED) (2)
David Rooker wrote: I'm against metered internet usage. It's trying to get more money for a se...

New Podcast: Celebrating Vinyl at Enterprise Records (1)
Jim wrote: Vinyl is one of the remaining beautiful things from a pre-Twitter world. ...

Shirt Party - Meet Local Ink Tonight (2)
Sharky wrote: Local Ink's t-shirts are listed at $80 - $92 on their site. Man, those shir...

The Monday Fix: DIY Funerals, AmazonFail and bacon-infused bourbon (1)
Dad Is Dying wrote: Speaking of DIY funerals: http://www.homefuneralmanual.org/...

Press Play with Videoport Jones - Yes Man, Doubt and The Day the Earth Stood Still (1)
Videoport Jones wrote: Justin, I am shocked, shocked I say, that you (or someone in the shadowy c...

Bracketstravaganza Winners and Losers (2)
JEB wrote: There is that Justin Bobble Head again! I want one!...