Nxt Blog Index
July 24, 2007
Getting straight on the YouTube debate

YouTube is a lot of things, including a distraction, a source of comedy, a repository of nostalgia and embarrassment.

But in the wake of last night’s CNN/YouTube debate of Democratic presidential candidates, many are saying YouTube is so much more.

"Revolutionary" is a word that’s getting a lot of play today following the debate where the candidates took questions submitted by people through YouTube Videos.

The idea is that these debates (a similar debate for Republican presidential job seekers is scheduled for September) are democracy at work, questions by the people to their would-be leaders.

Having only watched a little of the debate (is that the right word if the candidates were not addressing each other) it was interesting to see the variety of questions asked, as well as some of the theatrics employed – guitars, talking snowmen, firearms.

Then again, how could anyone take their eyes off the always impeccably dressed Silver Fox, doing his best as moderator. Keepin’ em honest...while lookin' good.

Online today the reaction seems all over the place, again with some people calling the exchange "groundbreaking," while others had questions.

- Over at Mother Jones they live-blogged the debate last night, and found more than a few humorous and insightful moments.

- The Digital Life blog at Information Week asks a good question – did the YouTube debate really change things for the better? If candidates can’t think on their feet, will we get more cardboard, formulaic answers?

- At the LA Times, an intern (because obviously the "young people" are the only ones who can interpret this Internet thing) says the questions were interesting, but suggests we got more of the same “dog and pony” from the candidates.

The San Francisco Chronicle’s Tech blog says the real winner in all of this was YouTube. The medium became the winner, not the candidates, and in the long run that could be a good thing.

Did you check out the debate or submit questions? Any lingering thoughts?

Posted by at 01:57 PM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index

Justin is a former newspaper intern and has the scar tissue to prove it. Justin has been a staff writer for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram since 2003, and in 2004 began writing a weekly column in the Monday Magazine.

If he had to pick a label, the column would fall under "youth culture," covering everything from high school dance etiquette, dealing with college debt, the resurgence of Roller Derby and Portland's one-of-a-kind music scene. This of course has not stopped him from answering letters to Santa Claus or writing about his experience riding shotgun in a drift car.

Justin is an export from the Midwest. He is a graduate of the University of Missouri and is originally from Minnesota. He enjoys bacon, cheap beer, redheads, Burt Reynolds jokes and wondering what the soundtrack to his life would sound like.

When he grows up he wants to be an international art thief. Or Captain America.

Until then he'll be bringing you dispatches about "the young people" and what they do.






WAYS TO LISTEN
1) Use the player above

2) Subscribe
ITUNES other podcast client

3) Direct Download
IE: Right-click select 'Save Target As
Mac: Control-click select 'Save Link As'.mp3
Bring on the Tights: Free Comic Book Day
Celebrating Vinyl at Enterprise Records
The NXT Roundtable: The economy & doughnuts
South by Southwest Interactive: Talking with Jay Smooth
The Night at Greendrinks
The NXT Roundtable
Day at the Newseum
Subject Bias: How to Feel
ROFLing with "Stuff White People Like"
Geekspeak with Pop Candy
A Green Eye for Fashion
Not My Job
What's next for Justin Alfond
Sittin' down with Stew n' Crew
Lessons with the Portland Music Foundation
Catching up with Opportunity Maine
Discussing Freedom Space
Spinout's Class of 2007
Free for All in Space
Flipping Records: WMPG's Annual Record Sale
An evening at the MECA art auction
Beats, award shows and life with Mike Clouds
The NXT Halloween Special
Chat with Davy Rothbart of FOUND Magazine
When Turtles Make Love *Warning: mature material
Derby night in America
The debut of Halo 3
A sit down with Santiago




Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
SOUND OFF: Facebook Flinches on Redesign (5)
ac wrote: A. Reader - I disagree that a web designer can't ask for user feedback. The...

Press Play with Videoport Jones: Quantum of Solace, Twilight and Andy Richter (1)
ac wrote: Here's a random compliment for Bolt. The animation must be pretty good o...

SXSW: A bubble waiting to burst? Summer camp for geeks? An underwater pyramid? (2)
Kate wrote: Are any of the Press Herald's articles EVER spell checked? It's a shame to ...

March Madness: The NXT Bracketstravaganza Returns (4)
Star Coach n Wife wrote: When we win, prefer the bobble head over the t-shirt for our prize!...

SXSW: Scenes from Austin (1)
Lila wrote: Cool pics...was someone rocking out from the back of their trunk? I've neve...

SXSW - LIVE: Chris Anderson & Guy Kawasaki (1)
Sharky wrote: It sounds like there's something inside when I shake it, but when I try to ...