Arts blog



Blog Index
October 13, 2008
Another endangered species.
Posted by William Fenn

While listening to the news, another story pops up about the dilemma of the Maine lobsterman. With high prices for fuel and bait as well as multi hundred thousand dollar boats and reduced access to the water it is easy enough to see the problems they face but now we have a relatively new source of trouble. It seems that the financial collapse in our country is killing the taste for lobster and the price of a landed harvest is collapsing into areas not seen in decades.

I have now been boatless for a year after sailing our 36 foot cutter out of Rockland for 18 years, and we always enjoyed seeing the working boats plying their trade as we coasted by. Mostly friendly but sometimes not, they were just part of the environment but perhaps now their days are numbered. With so many endangered species it seems that the forces of man are responsible for their fate and I cannot help but think that man is again a large factor in the lobster industry decline. Outside forces are usually to blame but in this case the lobstermans own efforts have a large measure of responsibility for their troubles. I'll go out on a limb here and say that I don't think that the lobster are over fished but instead clearly the market is over served.

In the approaches to Vinalhaven and Port Clyde as well as many other areas that we have visited, you could seemingly walk on the water, being held up by the carpet of pot buoys laid out before you.

The lobster certainly appreciate the plentiful food dropped conveniently on the ocean floor for them but the large number of traps seals the fate of the industry. In an effort to increase their incomes and provide growth in their industry, the lobsterman is instead killing the golden goose. It is always difficult to recognize when an industry is on the verge of collapse but the lobstermen need to recognize and act before economics and not species collapse kills their way of life. It is long past time to limit the total number of traps in the water in a meaningful way, providing a steady but reduced supply to the market and to allow individual lobstermen to own their license as some European countries do, thereby allowing them to sell the license or give it away at their time of retirement. If the lobster can again regain the description as a delicacy and not a commodity then the industry will have gone a long way toward survival. It's not too late to act, but once again we will likely see a waiting game played until bankruptcy and market forces simply cut away until only a few survive.

Posted by William Fenn at 06:47 AM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

As the wife of lobsterman - I must protest!!The lobster industry practices sustainable harvesting using trap limits and v-notching egg bearing females. The bouys in the water may be a mild hindrence for you in your pleasure boat, but they represent a way of life and a healthy source of food!! Without those bouys, there would be NO Maine lobster for the tourist industry. Millions of dollars that are mostly spent in-state by grateful fishing families provide jobs and a way of life that cannot be duplicated.
Your uninformed and ill spoken words hurt your fishing neighbors in a time when we should be supporting them!

Posted by Liz
October 13, 2008 01:58 PM

Liz,
Take a deep breath, count to ten, then actually read my post. No where do I say that lobster are overfished. They are simply oversupplied to the market. There are too many lobstermen supplying too much product to a too limited market. Add in the high price of boats, bait and traps as well as fuel etc and lobstering is an endangered way of life. Go ahead and deny it, as do way too many lobstermen as their industry suffers the decline brought on by too much supply and too high a price to obtain that supply while selling prices collapse around them. I stand by what I wrote.

Regards,
W fenn

Posted by W Fenn
October 14, 2008 09:58 PM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index
TABLE OF CONTENTS

Most Recent Comments
FairPoint Communications -- Much Too Little to Be So Big (2)
Peter Hayward wrote: Peter A piece of data data that did not make it into the essay above--ju...

Can We Be Too Careful? (20)
Sharky wrote: Dag nab system.......

Where's my bailout? (2)
wharfrat70 wrote: This hits the nail right on the head. Hate seeing my tax dollars go to bai...

Freedom vs. "Equality" (1)
willieA wrote: You failed to mention that Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe have been in the...

Forget this N word and get the banks lending again (1)
Peter Cutler wrote: Certainly the banks need to start lending again and it is obvious that inst...

Will It Work? (1)
Letter to Collins wrote: It will never work and inflation is going to be like an angry wolf at the d...

Would You Take THIS Professor’s Economic Advice? (3)
Peter Cutler wrote: What "myths" am I advocating? I certainly am in favor of "reform of Fede...

Are Maine media critics piling on the Portland Press Herald? (3)
wrote: Love you Sparky! Go boy go!...

Archives By date
July 08 (38)
June 08 (39)
May 08 (27)





RSS
Subscribe



Interested in becoming one of our community bloggers? Send us an e-mail.