Bump-Draft Blog Index
February 21, 2008
Robby Gordon penalty too harsh

R. Gordon022108.jpg


Yesterday it was announced that Robby Gordon was being penalized for an unapproved front bumper cover. He was dinged 100 driver and owner points. In addition, his crew chief, Frank Kerr, was fined $100,000 and suspended for the next six races. It seems like a pretty stiff penalty for him and his crew.

What do you think?

I'll be back tomorrow with my picks for California.


Posted at 09:40 AM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

So much for not being so heavy handed with the penalties this year.

100 points dropped him to 40th in points. Why didn't they just take all the points away? That's just plain cruel.

Posted by racefan
February 21, 2008 10:22 AM

It is a shame that Nascar would come down so hard on something that seems only to be a technicality. It certainly does not back up their plan to cut costs and help smaller teams. Just goes to show that as much as things change they stay the same. Inconsistencies before the first race of the year. Incredible.

Posted by son of racefan
February 21, 2008 01:01 PM

But isn't 100 pts consistent with the points reductions given to those that received them for CoT infractions last year?

You can't complain about NASCAR inconsistency and be inconsistent in your position.

That said, it's my understanding no where in the Mythical Rulebook is a clause that mitigates or excuses for "intent."

The motivations behind why a rule was broken, intentional or inadvertent, isn't taken into account. The car was presented at tech-inspec with illegal parts.

End of story.

Posted by marc
February 21, 2008 04:03 PM

Robby's nose was wrongly provided to him in a last minute manufacturer change. Nascar states that the nose will be legal as soon as they approve it for the new body. They also note that the only difference between the noses is decal placement.

I'll retract my earlier statement where I said that it was an inconsistent penalty. It was a consistent penalty for COT violations, but this was an inconsistent crime. Dale Jr's team manufactured wing supports with different holes. Hendrick's team formed fenders that were outside the templates.

Robby's infraction was an oversight that would have fit all of the templates provided by Nascar. Not having worked with Dodges before, his body men might not have known the difference. Either way, he would have gained no competitive advantage with the "illegal" nose had it made it to the track.

And it is not the end of the story until the appeal is made final. The only place I have seen support for Nascar's penalty is here in this blog.

Posted by son of racefan
February 21, 2008 06:53 PM

Junior's violations were also on the Nationwide car, not the Sprint car.

Robby had a good finish, too. He's another guy that doesn't fit the Nascar mold as a model driver. He just can't catch a break.

Posted by racefan
February 21, 2008 11:16 PM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index

Jennifer is the newsroom
administrative assistant and executive
assistant to the editor for the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram. She is married, lives in Pownal with her husband and son, and has been following NASCAR for many years.

About this blog:
I am hopeful that this will be a place where people can air their two cents' worth about a race, catch up on the gossip and share their opinions on the rules and regulations of NASCAR. I have always felt that there has been a need for such a place in Maine and that this blog helps to fill the void.



Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
Talladega thoughts and caution recap (5)
Earnhardt, Jr. wrote: What NASCAR needs to do is prohibit Carl Edwards from racing at Talladega. ...

Talladega preview and pick (1)
son of racefan wrote: I know Racefan picked Tony as well, but he will be hard to bet against this...

Boris Said suffers burns in wreck (3)
j wrote: I am going to pick JR to win, if he drives backwards....

Phoenix thoughts and caution recap (3)
Mïk wrote: @R Johnson-Boring!?! A mile track is NOT boring. Maybe NASCAR isn't for you...

Phoenix preview and pick (4)
Ella wrote: I am hoping Mark Martin gets a win. He certainly has the talent. Hope the...

Texas thoughts/Caution recap/Does Junior need an eye exam? (17)
Earnhardt, Jr. wrote: Racefan, I think you also made the million dollar statement. I wish he cou...

Texas preview and pick (2)
racefan wrote: What's it been? A couple weeks without Kyle's domination and a win? I'll pi...

Obama did NOT order GM and Chrysler out of NASCAR (7)
son of racefan wrote: Nascar is a great marketing tool for auto manufacturers. Many people buy a...