PPH Book Club Blog Index
March 30, 2009
Shifting certainties
Posted by Angela Muhs

That pretty much sums up the whole book, but I thought it also was the story of Lizzy and Drew.

About halfway through the book, I didn't hold out much hope for Lizzy and Drew's marriage. My certainty swelled in the heart-rending scene where she confesses that she's been going to talk to Harry Griggs, the "bad Samaritan" as Drew calls him. Drew, predictably, is furious. Before he storms out, he says to her, "You expect too much of me."

I liked both characters, and I wanted to see them make it work. But I didn't blame either of them for what was happening. I think we've all seen or known couples like that -- two people who expect something the other one can't give.

But then, after Lizzy has stolen the files and learned about the accusations against Father Mike, Drew gives her what she needs: He believes that Father Mike, who we now know didn't die, was in her room.

I ended the book feeling hope, hope that their move will make things right, hope that they'll have a family of their own. And hope, of course, that their relationship with Father Mike (I can't stop calling him that) will turn out all right.

How did you feel at the end of the book ? Were you satisfied with the ending?

Posted at 05:38 PM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

I thought the ending was full of hope also.

It was interesting to note that Vivienne and Fr. Mike had been able to keep the secret for years, but Charlie was incapable of keeping the secret. Consequently, we readers were able to see all sides of what keeping a secret can do to a people who were involved, like Vivienne and Fr. Mike, who were indirectly involved, like Lizzy, and someone not really involved at all, like Charlie.

Posted by Laura
March 31, 2009 06:37 AM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index


About the bloggers

Andi Jackson-Darling is the Assistant Director/Reference librarian at the Falmouth Memorial Library. (more)

Shirley Helfrich is a district consultant for the Maine State Library, based in Portland. (more)

Sarah McGinnis is a Publicist for Tilbury House, a small independent book publisher in Gardiner. (more)

Angie Muhs is the Press Herald's deputy managing editor/online. (more)

RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
Shifting certainties (1)
Laura wrote: I thought the ending was full of hope also. It was interesting to note t...

If you haven't finished, don't read this posting (3)
Laura wrote: The thing I loved about this book is that it was full of moral questions, b...

Two reminders (1)
Laura wrote: Any Bitter Thing is my favorite of those we have read. I thought it was gr...

Running on empty? (4)
Andi wrote: I don't know that I doubt his innocence in the accusations from his houseke...

Questions for Monica Wood? (7)
Brita wrote: How exciting that Monica will be here to chat with readers! We're so lucky ...

Loss and remembrance (1)
Laura wrote: I think Lizzy could very well have seen Uncle Mike. Her experience seems m...

"Maine Speech" (1)
Laura wrote: I am "from away," having lived here eight years. There is definitely a Mai...

March: Sneaking up on us (2)
E Quint wrote: It looks like there should be a youth book selection and an adult selection...

Archives
By date