PPH Book Club Blog Index
March 19, 2009
Running on empty?
Posted by Andi Darling

When you're feeling really hungry, running on empty, have you ever found yourself eating the first thing edible you find in the fridge? Lizzy reminds me of such a starving woman, taking in whatever is offered her. Is Lizzy trying to fill the gaps in her life left by her parents death, her uncle's removal from her life by the church and then his death. And when we learn she is hit by a car while running away from her husband, who is about to leave her as well, we as readers feel overwhelmed by the losses in her life. Even the man we come to know as Harry Griggs, leaves Lizzy on the side of the road after her accident, even a stranger leaves her to die alone.

I don't remember, in Wood's description of Drew's and Lizzy's courtship, of Lizzy ever stating that she loved Drew. The relationship came together from their acknowledgment of the other being "The one who will save me... " Their marriage begins breaking down and Drew meets a woman at one of the weddings he photographs. Drew does state after Lizzy's accident that he didn't know if he would've left Lizzy, but the unknown and the memory of what occurred between them just before Lizzy was hit is still between them.

I find I don't want to follow my usual regiment with this Read Around Maine selection. I usually only read the chapters or stories we will be discussing for the week. I plan on breaking with tradition this time and plan on finishing Wood's novel this evening. Although we as readers have been presented with what appears to be pretty much the full story, there are too many slightly dangling threads for me to really believe I know all there is to know about Wood's characters. At this point, should we really believe that Father Mike was innocent? The very beginning of the novel starts with Lizzy stating "I tell this with the authority of memory". And yet in the next few paragraphs we hear that the fourteen year old girl who hit Lizzy has said enough times that she thought she hit a deer, that the girl comes to accept or believe that she really thought she hit a deer and not a person.

Posted at 06:35 PM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

Andi, I'm wondering what clues have led you to doubt whether Father Mike was innocent.

Do others agree with Andi?

Posted by Angie
March 20, 2009 01:27 PM

I think Father Mike is guilty of something with Vivienne, but is definitely innocent of any wrong doing with Lizzy.

As for clues, he and Vivienne seem to have a bit too close of a relationship. I think a line has been crossed between them.

Posted by Laura
March 22, 2009 04:08 PM

Like you Andy, I "broke the rules" and could not wait to finish. I spent last Sunday afternoon galloping thru the rest of the book because I also wanted to find out what else we were missing. Although the opening chapters appear to present a neatly tied up package, the niggling thought kept popping up that we weren't seeing everything. I kept wondering how much of today's problems with priests and young children I was projecting into the stories, and kept hoping I was wrong. So I had to read on. I'll not go further with comments 'til everyone else catches up. I will say that I found the ending soul satisfying but I will leave it there for now.

Posted by Tina
March 23, 2009 09:54 PM

I don't know that I doubt his innocence in the accusations from his housekeeper. I just feel like there is more going on than we have been told. I think the line "I tell you this with the authority of memory". is what triggered my own "doubts". I'm of an age where I realize just how fragile memory really is!

Posted by Andi
March 24, 2009 04:56 PM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index


About the bloggers

Andi Jackson-Darling is the Assistant Director/Reference librarian at the Falmouth Memorial Library. (more)

Shirley Helfrich is a district consultant for the Maine State Library, based in Portland. (more)

Sarah McGinnis is a Publicist for Tilbury House, a small independent book publisher in Gardiner. (more)

Angie Muhs is the Press Herald's deputy managing editor/online. (more)

RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
If you haven't finished, don't read this posting (3)
Laura wrote: The thing I loved about this book is that it was full of moral questions, b...

Two reminders (1)
Laura wrote: Any Bitter Thing is my favorite of those we have read. I thought it was gr...

Running on empty? (4)
Andi wrote: I don't know that I doubt his innocence in the accusations from his houseke...

Questions for Monica Wood? (7)
Brita wrote: How exciting that Monica will be here to chat with readers! We're so lucky ...

Loss and remembrance (1)
Laura wrote: I think Lizzy could very well have seen Uncle Mike. Her experience seems m...

"Maine Speech" (1)
Laura wrote: I am "from away," having lived here eight years. There is definitely a Mai...

March: Sneaking up on us (2)
E Quint wrote: It looks like there should be a youth book selection and an adult selection...

White on Dogs (1)
Laura wrote: Has anyone reread White's children's books as a result of this online book ...

Archives
By date