PPH Book Club Blog Index
January 28, 2009
What Makes a Criminal?
Posted by Shirley Helfrich

Most people probably wouldn't call the main character of this story, Rebecca Brown, a criminal...yet. But in the chapter "Criminal" we learn of the events that lead her down this path. At the beinning of the chapter she tells us she hasn't ever stolen anything until the day when she takes a magazine from the doctor's office.

She wants to finish a story in the magazine about a balding man who leads a mundane life. The magazine story ends with "The man's wife wanted more from life than Saturday trips to the hardware store" so the wife leaves him.

At the end of this chapter, Rebecca also appears to be leaving her old life and heading for a new one. I'm not sure what terrible thing she is planning as she packs up barbecue starter, ripped up postcards from the mother who deserted her, a shirt for her boyfriend, and two cigarette lighters. But it's clear that her intent is to get arrested.

Rebecca is another one of this book's characters I feel sorry for -- circumstances seem to destine a tragic path for them. Her mother left, her minister father kept her prisoner, her boyfriends deserted or made fun of her, and she was unable to hold down a job. Rebecca craves attention and sympathy, and it's sad that the only person who provides it is a distant telephone operator with a soothing voice and manner at the company selling shirts.

Rebecca's math teacher Olive was the only person to reach out to her, an offer that was rejected. Was there anything that could have saved this lonely girl? What do you think she did next?

Posted at 10:41 AM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?








Blog Index


About the bloggers

Andi Jackson-Darling is the Assistant Director/Reference librarian at the Falmouth Memorial Library. (more)

Shirley Helfrich is a district consultant for the Maine State Library, based in Portland. (more)

Sarah McGinnis is a Publicist for Tilbury House, a small independent book publisher in Gardiner. (more)

Angie Muhs is the Press Herald's deputy managing editor/online. (more)

RSS
Subscribe
Most Recent Comments
If you haven't finished, don't read this posting (3)
Laura wrote: The thing I loved about this book is that it was full of moral questions, b...

Two reminders (1)
Laura wrote: Any Bitter Thing is my favorite of those we have read. I thought it was gr...

Running on empty? (4)
Andi wrote: I don't know that I doubt his innocence in the accusations from his houseke...

Questions for Monica Wood? (7)
Brita wrote: How exciting that Monica will be here to chat with readers! We're so lucky ...

Loss and remembrance (1)
Laura wrote: I think Lizzy could very well have seen Uncle Mike. Her experience seems m...

"Maine Speech" (1)
Laura wrote: I am "from away," having lived here eight years. There is definitely a Mai...

March: Sneaking up on us (2)
E Quint wrote: It looks like there should be a youth book selection and an adult selection...

White on Dogs (1)
Laura wrote: Has anyone reread White's children's books as a result of this online book ...

Archives
By date